Monday, August 27, 2012

Stratification


more data on increasing stratification due to Recession bailouts.

possible worksheet article for strat/gender strat (and find other, first one about the woman named in the artilce)

what's happening to the middle class? more complex?

video from Omar:  https://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=QPKKQnijnsM

Ch. 8: Stratification

Because cultures are so diverse, we find that they differ on almost everything we look at. There are very few cultural universals we can study, one of them has been the "incest taboo." Another universal is that ALL societies rank people systematically in a hierarchy. This is called
stratification.

Stratification determines how resources are distributed in a population.

Paradoxically, the more resources a society has, the less equal this distribution is.
This short video explains this paradox that abundance causes inequality (note the material determinism here)

Hunter/gatherers - 1 calorie expended for every 3 calories gained

Horticultural and pastoral - 1:5
Agricultural - 1:50
Industrial - 1:5,000



Stratification has 4 principles:

  • It is a property of a society, not of individuals.
    • even though we as individuals tend to think of ourselves (in terms of our talent and effort) relative to others around us.
  • It frequently carries over from one generation to the next, depending on the ease of social mobility.
    • How do parents pass on position to kids?
    • Depending on whether the system is "closed" or "open," some people have social mobility, which can be upward or downward, but most people in our society don't move very far over their life courses.
    • Some data on the US here.  Notice that it's hard to move up from the bottom, but also to move down from the top.
  • While all societies do it, they vary on the combination of criteria, or socio-economic status factors (SES): prestige, wealth, and power. How does our society do it? A bit of each. Configurations vary widely by occupation. Status consistency refers to whether these factors match up - how commensurable various measures are: money, power, prestige.
    • Religious leaders and politicians have power and prestige, but relatively low wealth.
    • Doctors and entertainers have money and prestige, but relatively low power.
    • Lawyers and business leaders (CEOs) have money and power, but relatively low prestige.
    • College professors like me don't usually make much money; we have a moderate amount of power in that sometimes our research affects public policy and we can influence our students' thinking, and we have a lot of prestige in society. Thus, we have low status consistency.
    • If you are in the military, rank (prestige) comes with certain authority over others in the chain of command (power), and a specific pay grade (money). Thus, they have high status consistency.
  • It involves not just inequality in the hierarchy, but also ideologies (a.k.a. belief systems) that explain and justify it. (people get what they deserve vs. cognitive dissonance)(poverty may drain cognitive resources)
    • Systems of inequality must define themselves as fair... for example "it is good for someone to have more money, power, or status than someone else, because they are smarter, work harder, or are in some way better and more deserving." ...societies think there should be reasons linking who you are and what you have... post-hoc rationalizing. (Again, like in the chapter on deviance, if you DON'T think society is just, you are more likely to find criminal actions, or political revolutions, to be plausible.)


Caste -----Class ------ Perfect meritocracy


Caste - one's status in the hierarchy is ascribed rather than achieved. There is little social mobility, and rigid boundaries between the strata.


e.g., in India, caste determines your occupation:

  1. Brahmin (priest)
  2. Kshatriya (politician/warrior)
  3. Vaishya (merchants)
  4. Sudra (laborers)

Caste systems keep people in the company of their own kind – norms enforce this with belief in "pollution," which normalizes homophily and endogamous marriage.

Accepting one's place in the social order is seen as a
moral duty, which shows merit and loyalty to society, just as a capitalist work ethic became a moral duty for Protestants (Weber)


The United Kingdom – The RISE of Class FROM Caste

Under the aristocratic feudal system, 5% hereditary nobles owned most land, had no “occupation” and viewed work as beneath them. Most people were commoners or serfs, who worked the land and paid rent.

The industrial revolution drained farms of serfs; they moved to cities and got wage-jobs which allowed them to save money and eventually challenge the nobility.


England still retains vestigial caste-like elements, such as the hereditary House of Lords (part of their Parliament, like the Senate is part of our Congress). Less social mobility than in U.S.


The Soviet Union: Classlessness via Communism?

Russian experiment of socialism and perestroika (restructuring).
There still was stratification under "communism":

  1. High officials (apparatchiks)
  2. Intelligentsia
  3. Manual workers
  4. Peasants and farmers.

They did virtually eliminate abject poverty (and opulent wealth), but the average standard of living was much less than in other (capitalist) industrial countries.

Gorbechev reduced centralized control to stimulate growth, allowing local industries to expand. This was evidence of
structural social mobility – shift in position of large numbers due to changes in society, not individuals.

China – after WWII, went "communist" with central coordination of farms and factories. Mao declared all work equally important. Similar results to Russia.


In the late 70s a gradual shift began to more capitalism and manufacturing, especially along coastal areas. Since then, inequality has increased dramatically, and the current stratification system is a mix of the old political hierarchy and the new business hierarchy.



IDEOLOGY of INEQUALITY

A stratification system also consists of the beliefs that support it.
For example, India's caste system is accepted because of belief in dharma (duty), karma, and reincarnation.
The United Kingdom's old caste system was accepted because of belief in predestination and the "divine right of kings."
The beliefs that allow us to accept our American brand of stratification are beliefs such as that "rich people are rich because they are smart and hard-working, and poor people are poor because they are lazy and foolish."


Structural-Functionalism


Herbert Spencer on "social Darwinism," p. 216 – is inequality a mechanism ensuring the survival of the fittest?

  • This view is not supported by modern sociologists, but it is common in pop culture and the media

Davis-Moore thesis, p. 217 – inequality is functional for society. Inequality is found in every society, so it's a pattern, and structural-functionalists look for functions. The greater the importance of a position, the more rewards society attaches to it as symbolic markers. They provide motivation to the smart and talented to work harder, better, and longer. This may explain why many people go into medicine, business, law, politics, etc...

  • Does this explain why Oprah makes more in a day than Obama makes in a year? Does society value a talk show more than the leader of our country?
  • How many soldiers are worth a CEO of a tech company?
  • Does this apply to teachers assigning grades, A through F?

So what's the difference between Herbert Spencer's view and the Davis-Moore Thesis?


Survival of the fittest (social Darwinism) focuses on
individual traits that propel certain individuals to the top: how competitive, smart, strong, cut-throat are you? Only the strong survive, the cream rises to the top.

Davis & Moore focus on what positions society thinks are important. So it is
the position that gets loaded with rewards that kind magnetically draw people who are competent enough to do it. Thus, inequality is a mechanism that makes sure the smartest, hardest working people are doing the most important kinds of things.

Social Conflict Approach


Marx on conflict between bourgeoisie and proletariat.

Scientific management, assembly line, etc. produces alienation, less SES for workers.
Makes workers poorer and poorer, exploits their labor to make profit.

So why no Marxist revolution? Even the poor have a higher standard of living than in the past!

Also, diffusion of ownership through stock programs, etc, allows pressure to be relieved.
Diffusion of power through unions (which "let off steam" and provide a bulwark against low pay and other exploitation), consequently laws to provide safety and security, which is why a conflict theorist would be concerned about the recent political situation in Madison – collective bargaining rights over conditions of labor.


Symbolic Interactionism

Normally takes a micro-level look at peoples' day to day interactions and how we construct their meaning. But, as we have said, stratification happens on the level of society, but of course we, as individuals, find ourselves within certain strata. We generally can see where we stand relative to others, and that colors our perception of the world. We internalize our SES as part of our self-concept, and this affects how we interact with others (via language, and symbols we use) and what we buy (conspicuous consumption).

Remember, this perspective is founded on a philosophical doctrine of
ideal determinism, and so we can also see how the material world around us is shaped by the meanings we attach to it!

WEBER – Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism (a symbolic interactionist explanation for capitalist structures coming from religious ideology.)



America
- have you heard? We've been going through a bit of a recession lately.  (videoWhat has that done to our system of stratification?  This short video on class disparities gives us an idea of how pronounced inequality is today.
What has that done to our system of stratification? Here is a graph of the share of income taken home by different segments of the population.
As we've talked about before, American society kind of measures peoples' status by their monetary worth.
Here is an indication of the magnitude of the gap between rich and poor
: if you made minimum wage adjusted for inflation, and you started working in the year 246 B.C. and saved every penny, you would have just caught up to what the CEO of Hewlett Packard took home in just one year, 2009. that's an extreme example, but how does the picture look more generally? How much inequality is there? This closely matches WEALTH chart on p. 201 – difference between income and wealth?
  • the wealth of most people as a house and a car, and the wealth of the rich as stocks and investments that PRODUCE income
CLASS IN THE U.S.A.(compare to new class in the U.K.?)
  • We are becoming less of a “middle-class” society as inequality grows. A small minority have most of our wealth, better education, health, longer lives, etc.
  • prestige of different jobs in America (p.202)?
  • What are the classes?
    1. Upper class (about 5%)
      • upper-upper class gets their wealth through inheritance (i.e. old money)(a.k.a. "the 1%")
      • lower-upper class may have similar or even greater wealth, but they earned it somehow through their own efforts and abilities
    2. Middle class (about 35%)
      • upper-middle class are doctors, lawyers, engineers, businesspeople who are doing very well in terms of income; they have some wealth and investments that make additional money for them, too.
      • average middle class people tend to have white-collar jobs: they are managers, teachers, civil servants, and even some highly skilled blue-collar workers (tradesmen, contractors).  They usually have a bit of wealth, but it is almost entirely tied up in homes and retirement savings.
    3. Working class a.k.a. "lower-middle class" people (about 35%) are mostly blue-collar or service-industry workers with routinized jobs requiring little creativity.  They get few benefits and have little or no wealth, usually renting or perhaps owning inexpensive homes in poor neighborhoods. Their kids probably won't go to college.  They are vulnerable to illness and unemployment, since they probably lack health insurance and have no wealth to tide them over while looking for work after they lose a job.
    4. Lower class people a.k.a. "the working poor" (about 25%), if they have a job at all, have jobs that pay very little, have low prestige, and certainly offer no benefits or job security.  They are extremely vulnerable to illness and unemployment, and often rely on social safety nets to meet basic needs.
the language of subjective class... 

the continuing relevance of class... 


where is the money, block by block in America?

4:05 - POP QUIZ

FOR NEXT TIME
:
  • Read 207-217 and 248-252 Due






box on p. 205 – nickel and dimed – shows that low wage service work does not really reflect abilities or work-ethic. Does what a CEO makes really reflect the value of what he produces? Is he really worth 5,000 janitors? We are socialized by meritocratic capitalism to view these people are lazy or lacking ability, but those jobs take serious energy and mental/emotional effort.






How much inequality is there?

Beer and Population Analogy: Imagine that the US is represented by 10 people. The gross national resources are represented by 10 beers. Here are two ways of organizing the economy: the first is according to egalitarian principles. The second is a reflection of the current capitalist system. Which party would you rather attend?

---------------------------------------OR----------------------------------------------

This closely matches WEALTH chart on p. 224 – difference between income and wealth?
  • the wealth of most people as a house and a car, and the wealth of the rich as stocks and investments that PRODUCE income



WEBER: “SES” = cla$$ + status + power
Weber differs from Marx in predicting that socialism, while it may reduce MONEY inequality, would only replace it with POWER inequality (power elites in centralized bureaucratic system) (explains USSR)

KUZNETS CURVE – explanation caption p.222– developed by economists in 50's and 60's, predicted current uptick in inequality in post-industrial society. → explains why socialist revolutions took place in agrarian countries like russia and china, rather than industrial countries like US.



Health, Values & attitudes, politics, family and gender (p.231) (top of page on what women want)
Social Mobility – inter/intra generational
chart on p. 232
Is the American Dream still a reality? Or do we need to be asleep to believe it? - p.233
POVERTY
absolute vs. relative
reduce it by providing jobs AND childcare (p.239)
blame the poor vs blame society on p. 238,
Welfare – p. 240

Show poverty game? PLAYSPENT.ORG
OK QUIZ

POP QUIZ?
\



CHAPTER 10" GENDER STRATIFICATION






Patriarchy and institutional sexism

Gender and socialization redux

Why are people concerned about equal pay for equal work?
Why did our congress pass the Lilly Ledbetter Fair Pay Act in 2009?
Why do American women make $0.78 for every $1 earned by men? (worse in some states than others)
different tracks (and see the pay gap by occupation)
What are "pink-collar" jobs?
fewer hours
Who does the housework?

less skilled at negotiation

 speaking up for oneself
about 8 cents remain unaccounted for

Effects of shifting from an agricultural, to an industrial, to a post-industrial economy?

as we advance technologically, physicality becomes less important. Computer programmers need less strength than factory workers, who need less strength than farm laborers. But it is still "masculine" to be independant, self-supporting, a "bread-winner," but it is becoming less important to be physically strong to do that.
So is there a gender anomie for males? Is there a cultural compensation?



DEMMIAN FROM REDDIT:

Really? That's what the US Department of Labor says?
MYTH: Saying women only earn 77 cents on the dollar is a huge exaggeration – the “real” pay gap is much smaller than that (if it even exists).
REALITY: The size of the pay gap depends on how you measure it. The most common estimate is based ondifferences in annual earnings (currently about 23 cents difference per dollar). Another approach uses weekly earnings data (closer to an18 or 19 cents difference). Analyzing the weekly figures can be more precise in certain ways, like accounting for work hours that vary over the course of the year, and less accurate in others, like certain forms of compensation that don’t get paid as weekly wages. No matter which number you start with, the differences in pay for women and men really add up. According to one analysis by the Department of Labor’s Chief Economist, a typical 25-year-old woman working full time would have already earned $5,000 less over the course of her working career than a typical 25-year old man. If that earnings gap is not corrected, by age 65, she will have lost hundreds of thousands of dollars over her working lifetime. We also know that women earn less than men in every state and region of the country, and that once you factor in race, the pay gap for women of color is even larger.
MYTH: There is no such thing as the gender pay gap – legitimate differences between men and women cause the gap in pay, not discrimination.
REALITY: Decades of research shows a gender gap in pay even after factors like the kind of work performed and qualifications (education and experience) are taken into account. These studies consistently conclude thatdiscrimination is the best explanation of the remaining difference in pay. Economists generally attribute about 40% of the pay gap to discrimination – making about 60% explained by differences between workers or their jobs. However, even the “explained” differences between men and women might be more complicated. For example: If high school girls are discouraged from taking the math and science classes that lead to high-paying STEM jobs, shouldn’t we in some way count that as a lost equal earnings opportunity? As one commentator put it recently, “I don’t think that simply saying we have 9 cents of discrimination and then 14 cents of life choices is very satisfying.” In other words, no matter how you slice the data, pay discrimination is a real and persistent problem that continues to shortchange American women and their families.
MYTH: Women are responsible for the pay gap because they seek out flexible jobs or choose to work fewer hours. Putting family above work is why women earn less.
REALITY: Putting aside whether it’s right to ask women (or men) to sacrifice financially in order to work and have a family, those kinds of choices aren’t enough to explain away the gender pay gap. The gender gap in pay exists forwomen working full time. Taking time off for children also doesn’t explain gaps at the start of a career. And although researchers have addressed various ways that work hours or schedule might or might not explain some portion of the wage gap, there may be a “motherhood penalty.” This is based on nothing more than the expectation that mothers will work less. Researchers have found that merely the status of being a mother can lead to perceptions of lowered competence and commitment and lower salary offers.
The pay gap isn’t a myth, it’s a reality – and it’s our job to fix it.


Thursday, August 23, 2012

1: Introductions & Fundamentals

Hello students! Welcome to SocBlog, the class weblog for Introduction to Sociology.

Here's the agenda for our first day together...

00 - take attendance, pass out name cards

05 - introductions (instructor bio, go around and say name and program - if undecided, just say that)

20 - syllabus, collect Course Contracts
 

1:00 - Blackboard demo

What this blog IS:
A tool for the instructor to organize topics for in-class discussion, and post links to relevant websites and other content.

What this blog IS NOT:
A replacement for reading the textbook.  What I post here is what I plan to discuss in class, because I have found in the past that students have a little more difficulty understanding these topics.  I will not have time to discuss EVERYTHING in a chapter that could be on a test.  ANYTHING within the pages listed in the reading assignments in the syllabus schedule is potential test material... you may feel free to print out the blog entries and add them to your notes, but do not assume that printing out this blog is all the note-taking you need to do to be successful on the tests...

FOR NEXT TIME:
  • Read pp. 2-11 in Macionis
  • Complete the Technological Competency assignment (see assignment details by clicking the "Assignments" button in the menu bar to the left)

NEXT CLASS STARTS HERE

 3:00 - Attendance

3:05 - Go over Technological Competency assignment results

3:10 - So what's the big idea of sociology?  Let's delve into our textbook and find out.



Chapter 1

  • p. 8-9, 200+ years ago, industrialization + urbanization + political revolution ("enlightenment" ideals and scientific development from people like Copernicus, Galileo, and Newton) led Comte to coin the term sociology, as a method to describe society as it actually was rather than with abstract utopian theorizing. "Positivism" refers to positive, empirical facts as opposed to speculation.
  • People have always wondered and theorized about society (Plato, Confucius, Aristotle, the Romans, St. Thomas Aquinas, Shakespeare, etc..)
    • Comte saw early social thinkers as being in the THEOLOGICAL stage, viewing society as an expression of God's (or the gods') will.
    • The Renaissance period saw the change into a METAPHYSICAL stage of social thought, where society is seen as a natural phenomena that could be apprehended through reason alone, like Thomas Hobbes who saw it as the natural playing out of an original State of Nature of "all against all."
    • The SCIENTIFIC stage began with the work of famous scientists like Copernicus, Galileo, and Newton, who tried to understand the fundamental forces at work (theorizing) by looking at empirical evidence, and from these folks Comte applied this positivist method to society.


OK, so how exactly is sociology scientific?

(Powerpoint)


Another way to put it...



Science is a way of knowing, and a body of knowledge.


Sociology is related to anthropology, economics, political science, and history.

THEORY



What is a law?

A description of the relationship between facts. 
(Ex. gravity)
 
What is a theory?



An explanation of the relationship between facts.






What is a hypothesis?



A specific prediction, derived from a theory and designed to be tested.  The word comes from the Latin for "to suppose," so think of it like a way to test a theory: "Let's suppose your theory (i.e. explanation) is correct.  If we are held down to the surface of the Earth by an invisible noodly appendage of the Flying Spaghetti Monster, then..."  What would that imply?  Could you test it?





What is a "theoretical perspective"?
A way to orient yourself to what you see, like a lens that focuses on certain aspects of reality, while obscuring others.

METHODS
How can we know how people behave?

Surveys, interviews, focus groups, observation, ethnography, history, content analysis
STATISTICAL INFERENCE
populations = Census (expensive, hard to do)
samples and generalizability
random, stratified, convenience, snowball



THINKING SOCIOLOGICALLY
Look at the Chapter overview story on p. 2 – society influences a seemingly individual decision: who to love.
Arranged marriage? Gay marriage? Monogamy vs. polygamy/gyny/amory?

What about the decision to have children? see map on p. 4
Why do averages differ so? Macionis explains there are socio-economic factors like education, jobs, contraceptive technology, and cultural ideas about women's roles.
In 2012, the U.S. birth rate dropped to the lowest on record...

Another, even more individual decision: suicide – see chart on p. 5.
Emile Durkheim wrote one of the first true sociological studies on this topic.



What about the feeling of personal responsibility for our lives? What about agency?

Certainly, what we do affects our lives, but so do social forces – see story on p. 6 of changes in the economy, laws, and culture, creating conditions where lots of folks lose their jobs to outsourcing.

DISCUSS "WHAT DO YOU THINK?"


One of the things we do in sociology is inform laws: see p. 7 Sociology and Public Policy

What else is sociology good for? From a personal perspective:
  • Allows us to assess the truth of "common sense"
    • conventional wisdom can be false, contradictory, or overly simplified
  • Makes opportunities and constraints visible that many people do not see.
    • The sociological perspective allows us to peek behind the curtains of society, like in the Wizard of Oz
    • Shakespeare once wrote that "all the world's a stage, and all the men and women merely platers; they have their exits and entrances, and one man in his time plays many parts," like in a theater (dramaturgy)
  • Empowers us to be active participants in society.
    • regarding "social justice": knowing social forces exist does not deny our agency, but on the contrary it empowers us to interact with social forces to change the world
      • C Wright Mills – sociological imagination – seeing that our personal problems are public issues... Durkheim would say that these social forces, difficult to understand previously, were seen as mysterious and supernatural.
  • Helps us live in a diverse world – the farther you travel, the less you know
    • Helps us think critically about the relative strengths and weaknesses of our way of life.



FOR NEXT TIME:
  • Read pp. 10-13 in the textbook

Tuesday, August 14, 2012

2: Structural-Functionalism

7:30 - Attendance

7:35 - Theoretical Perspectives (orientations to the social world that focus our attention on certain aspects of society)



Starts with the question: WHY should society exist at all?
Instead of dissolving into atomized individuals pursuing our own narrow interests?

What explains societal stability, solidarity, and survival over time?


Views society as a complex system of parts that work together in order to create solidarity and stability. 


When we talk about "parts" we mean stable social patterns (known as "structures"), not isolated or unique events or social forms.  So "structures" are things like norms, customs, traditions, organizations, and institutions.


What these "structures" actually DO is known as their "function," and generally the function of social structures has to do with creating solidarity, or stability, or survival over time in the most efficient way possible.


So in the name "structural functionalism," structural means this “lens” focuses our attention on structures (stable social patterns) and, therefore, it does NOT focus our attention on things like conflicts and social change.  Functionalism means we also focus on explaining WHY certain structures exist in terms of WHAT THEY DO FOR SOCIETY.  


So the standard process that a structural functionalist follows looks like this:


  1. first you look around for stable patterns in the area you are interested in
  2. then, when a stable pattern is observed, you look for a function


Analogy: society is like an organism. Economy is like circulatory system, government is like brain, people are like cells, medical institutions are like immune system, etc...
  


Here are a few common social structures.  What functions might they serve?



people often shake hands when meeting for the first time






in a Catholic religious ceremony, everyone lines up and receives a communion wafer and a sip of wine






it has become more common to pay for goods and services with a credit card






every 4 years, Americans vote to elect a president



You can think of social groups and institutions in a kind of evolutionary way... if a new kind of structure randomly comes about, then it will be more likely to survive if it serves a useful function for the wider society around it. 


If it does do something useful, society will be more likely to "feed" it with the things it needs (members, resources, legal rights, etc...) and it will persist over time.  Social groups that don't stay unified usually die off, or split into more manageable groups.





So what is it that creates solidarity? Shared values? Common symbols? Systems of exchange?  Durkheim posited two ways this can happen:
  • Mechanical solidarity, cohesion and integration comes from the homogeneity (being of the same type) of individuals—people feel connected through similar work, educational and religious training, and lifestyle.  Society normally operates in a "traditional" way in small scale societies based around ties of familial networks.  "Mechanical" here is referring to people being somewhat interchangeable between different roles (since they are all of the same type) much like parts in a machine.
  • Organic solidarity comes from the interdependence that arises from specialization of work and the complementarities between people which occurs in modern, and industrialized societies. Although individuals perform different tasks and often have different values and interests, the order and solidarity of society depends on their reliance on each other to perform their specified tasks. "Organic" here is referring to the interdependence of the component parts, like in an organism (e.g., farmers produce the food to feed the factory workers who produce the tractors that allow the farmer to produce the food).



Societies that don't stay unified pretty much die, or split.

Most structures not only have manifest or intended functions, but also latent functions or unintended side-effects. For example, college as a marriage-broker, or sports as a way to keep kids out of trouble.


Sometimes there can also be social dysfunctions (negative effects) that can disrupt the order of society, or harm solidarity or survival.  What is functional for one category may be dysfunctional for another... people disagree.








For Next Time:
  • Read pp. 14-27
  • Come prepared to make a decision for your final project.
    • if it's a research paper, what will your topic be?
    • if it's a volunteer service project, what organization will you volunteer with?
    • if it's a Student Learning Showcase exhibit, what will your topic be?


have read "We Are Fractal Sheep"???

4: Symbolic Interactionism, reseach methods


Symbolic Interactionism 
 (Max Weber)
  This approach differs from the other two in that it kind of "zooms in" on society with a microscope, rather than zooming out and looking at the big picture.  This micro level approach focuses our attention on individual interactions, and leads us to view society as by-product.

The question we start with here is:  How does this abstract thing we call "society" result from the ongoing interactive experiences of millions or billions of people?




  • Institutions, organizations, and social structures are simply abstractions in our minds, combined with network patterns of interaction; all that is real are our individual interactions.



  • So the mind, and the concept of group belongingness, are crucial to being human as we know it. This is where Max Weber brings in his philosophy of ideal determinism - unlike Karl Marx who believed our material circumstances determine everything about our lives and how we think about ourselves, Weber believed that our ideas have "primacy" and they actually determine our material circumstances, rather than the other way around.
    • For example, in his book The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism, Weber argues that a new idea about religion and the meaning of life in this world caused a radical change in our physical and socio-economic environments.  OUR IDEAS CAN CHANGE OUR BEHAVIORS, WHICH CHANGE OUR WORLD.
A key observation that symbolic interactionists make is simply that people act toward things based on the meaning those things have for them, and these meanings come from the individual's interpretation of social interactions (always in a cultural context) involving language.


from Reddit - "My name is Claire. I am 18 years old. And I decided to shave my head."
I had a number of reasons for doing so, the main three being: Long, dark hair is just too hot for Arizona summers, I have better things to do than tame my thick, frizzy hair every morning, and I was just plain curious. Considering this was a personal decision, I was surprised at just how much everyone, mainly completely strangers, had suddenly taken an intense interest in this choice. It’s been about a month since the initial shaving, and I’d like to share some of the most frequent comments, questions and situations I’ve encountered:
*“What happened?!” 
*“Why would you shave off your beautiful hair?” 
*“Don’t worry; it’ll grow back in no time.” 
*“Can I touch it?” (This from people I have never met.) • 
* <Middle school girls pointing> *“Oh but you were so pretty!” 
*“Oh my god. What does your boyfriend/mom/dad/family think?" 
*“Wow you’re so brave.” 
*“Is this some form of rebellion?”
I’ve also encountered the situation where people think I’m very sick. I made a Target run one day; I had a very bad cold, I wasn’t wearing any makeup and the sweats I was wearing were filthy. I was asked multiple times if I needed help carrying things, three people let me go ahead in line, and I heard a woman tell her children, “Don’t stare at the poor girl.” These people were all incredibly empathetic and good people for trying to help… but I don’t have cancer.
Most of the comments regarding my head were not meant to be malicious. But I think it’s pretty easy to see the problem with them. Most people cannot fathom why a teenage girl would willingly go bald. Heterosexual girls are expected to make personal decisions based on the preferences of heterosexual boys. I didn’t lose my hair from a disease, I didn’t shave it for a part in a play or movie, I didn’t shave it because my mother has a disease and I’m supporting her and I didn’t shave it to make a point. I shaved my head because my hair is hot and cumbersome. That’s it.
Now, I was semi-prepared for society to view me differently, but I wasn’t prepared for what happened next. I consider myself a strong, independent person who doesn’t let the opinions of others affect how I dress or perceive myself… but I have noticed a shift in my self-perception. I’ve always been a feminine person. I love dresses and bows, but since I’ve shaved my head I’ve been wearing dresses and skirts almost exclusively and I’ve been wearing more makeup than I ever have. About two weeks in I realized it was taking more time for me to get ready now than when I had hair. I started paying attention to my internal dialogue during my morning routine. I realized I had become self-conscious about my femininity and was using skirts and makeup to “prove” to the world that yes, I was still a girl. And all this had happened without my noticing.
I had bought into the idea that hair somehow defines a girl… and a girl without hair must be a ‘butch lesbian’. Which just isn’t me. I don’t regret shaving my head, I thought it was a liberating experience and it truly forced me to confront some preconceived notions about my actions, decisions, and societal expectations. Despite all of the above, my bald head has given me confidence and security in who I am. NoRegrets right?


  • Brainstorm the "meaning" of sexual intercourse?


    • THAT we are sexual is is determined by a biological imperative toward reproduction. But HOW we are sexual (where, when, how often, with whom, and why) depends on what we have learned from our culture, with meanings transmitted to us by others in our networks... 


  • How can gun violence be a Rorschach test? (link1) (and see recent December, 2012 shooting)
















All this stuff means that all of our social structures (including norms, beliefs, and values, as well as organizations/institutions) are "socially constructed" on this scaffold of culture, that we learn through an interactive process with specific other individuals.


CAVEAT: saying that things are "socially constructed" often provokes a response that, therefore, the things in question are not really "real."  This reaction somewhat misses the point.  Think about the example of a house.  Is a house really "real"?  After all, a "house" is physically constructed by a social group... does that mean it's not really a house because, in actual physical reality, it is literally just a bunch of rocks, boards, glass, and steel?  No, of course it IS a house because we get to assign that meaning to that particular collection of materials in that particular configuration.  Culture and language give us this ability.  

The interesting part of all this for a symbolic interactionist is that we have influence over culture and language precisely because they are generated in these micro-interactions in which we have agency. 


Discuss dramaturgy

All the world's a stage,
And all the men and women merely players;
They have their exits and their entrances,
And one man in his time plays many parts,
-Shakespeare

Discuss social exchange, economic rationality, and game theory.
  • The Prisoner's Dilemma – two suspects are arrested by the cops but there is not enough evidence to convict. The cops separate them and offer each the same deal: confess and testify against your partner, and we'll cut you a break.  
    • If your partner stonewalls us, but you testify against him, we'll let you go free and convict him on a serious charge, and he'll get a major sentence (20 years hard time).
    • If neither of you one testifies against the other, we'll be able to convict both of you on a lesser charge and you'll each get a minor sentence (1 year hard time). 
    • If you both testify against each other, we'll get you both convicted of the serious offence, but in light if your cooperation you will each receive a reduced sentence (5 years hard time).
Each prisoner is assured that the other will not know about his decision before the end of the investigation.  Keep in mind that they do not know each others' personalities well enough to predict what the other will choose to do.
How should the prisoners act?  How would you act?







Even though this is a hypothetical situation designed as a thought experiment, the logic can be applied to more practical situations in society.  For example, here is conversation I heard on the radio recently about the recession we've gone through: 


One guy said, "No matter how bad things get, I will keep spending on my hobby of classic car reconstruction, because when you tighten your purse strings, you choke the economy." 

Then another guy called in to say, "Well, I'm not going to spend-spend-spend just because the economy needs me to, because that leaves me penniless with no savings for emergencies or for retirement... and what if the economy continues to get worse? Then those who've spent spent spent are REALLY hurting!"

So sure, if everyone were to spend everything they have, that would definitely get the economy juiced up and lots of new jobs would get created.  But it is rational for an individual to save for emergencies, in a sense betraying the collective out of personal self-interest.  If everyone acts only out of self-interest, we all suffer from a bad economy!

The problem is that what is "rational" varies, depending on what level of analysis you are thinking on: that of the individual, or that of the collective.



Recapping theoretical approaches: 

Structural-functionalism
  • Emile Durkheim
  • Macro scale
  • Positivist methods
    • likes quantitative, empirical data
    • strives for scientific objectivity (unbiased)
  • 2-step process
    • 1. look for social structures (patterns of interaction, such as norms, traditions, organizations, etc...)
    • 2. identify functions of those structures (usually stability, solidarity, or survival)

The Social Conflict Approach

  • Karl Marx
  • Macro scale
  • Critical methods
    • explicitly political, no bones about it
    • focuses on need for change – should society exist as it does?  how can it be improved?
    • rejects the ideal of scientific neutrality as implicitly conservative (supports the status quo)
    • Realize that even our moral preferences are shaped by culture
  • 2-step process
    • 1. look for moving targets (any social change: wars, revolutions, protests, conflicts, etc...)
    • 2. identify a disparity or inequality that may explain why pressure built up to cause change (usually money/wealth, political power, or social prestige)


Symbolic Interactionism

  • Max Weber
  • Micro scale (zooms in on small-scale interactions)
  • Interpretive methods
    • likes qualitative data, such as from ethnography (participant observation)
    • focuses on how individuals learn and create subjective meaning, and how and why they act on that meaning in the context of their lives "Verstehen"








6: Socialization

Socialization: From Childhood to Adulthood


7:30 - Attendance

...

Continue discussion of Chapter 2: Culture
Norms: laws, mores, folkways

 example in football.

How does culture change over time?


  • invention
  • discovery
  • diffusion



Theoretical approaches...


Structural Functionalism - Culture is a complex strategy for meeting human needs.  What does this mean?

Look for patterns and universals.

Stability of society rests on core values shared by all.


Social Conflict Approach – if there is inequality, assume that culture benefits the powerful by teaching us to accept the system.

Accepting "material determinism" means that we view external culture as something that shapes our patterns of thought and behavior.





8:00 - Chapter 3: Socialization



The importance of social experience

Nature vs. Nurture debate
(instincts vs. learned behavior)
(walking vs. Talking, as I said last time)
(or, perhaps they're both affected by one another?)



Nurture IS our nature, just as culture is our nature.

We have evolved so that we have instincts to teach extra-genetic information (traditions, ways of life, beliefs and values) to our kids using memes.


Isolation


-opening story of girl in closet, Anna... thoughts?



-Rhesus monkeys (Harlow)

  -how much isolation could they recover from, and eventually act like normal monkeys?

  -how much isolation did it take to substantially and IRREVERSIBLY disrupt their development?



Important socialization research

Freud: tripartite model of the mind: Id, Ego, Superego

Piaget: cognitive development: Sensorimotor -> Preoperational -> Concrete Operational -> Formal operational

Kohlberg: moral reasoning development: Preconventional -> conventional -> post-conventional (Kant)
(this kid is pre-conventional... when mommy takes the butcher knife away...)


Gilligan: extended Kohlberg's work by applying gender
Boys: Justice, fairness, rational rules
Girls: care/responsibility, emotional bonds

Horton-Cooley: the "Looking-Glass Self"


8:35 - Split into small groups, plan for Commercial Critique assignment

Group 1: Marisol, Brittany, Scott, Ally
Group 2: Adrienne, Steve, Joe, Carly
Group 3: Nick, Michelle, Arianna, Hailey
Group 4: Sarah, Lindsay, Hunter, Becky


GOOD example:

Nestle's Bottled Water commercial appeared to have a socialization effect, communicating cultural beliefs and norms.  It's not the focus of the ad, but a side-effect is a reinforcement that it is a normal behavior for men to be sitting on the couch watching TV while the women's role is to be taking care of them.  There is also a belief of nature vs nurture.  As we have learned, humans are not born with instincts for their cultural behavior - they must learn to develop these traits.  As the young mother watches, she notices her son imitating each move that his father makes, including drinking a sugary soft drink.  It occurs to her that a better habit for her son to develop would be imitating his dad drinking a bottle of water.  By implying that she can change his learned behavior, she has established that nurture is more powerful than nature.    


BAD example:

go to youtube type in (best ad ever - winner of 2010 best tv advertisement award hd )
its the mouse commercial
This ad is implying by eating the cheese you will have supper human strength




more examples... beef jerky campaign... this as supplementary watching...

... Virgin Air commercial implying white men are born to be pilots and engineers, while blacks and women are born to servile roles...


FOR NEXT TIME:

Read pp. 71-81
Be prepared with your group to show a commercial advertisement, present your analysis of a belief, norm, or value, and facilitate a brief class discussion.  Use the new forum I created just for this assignment in the Discussion Board.

-------------------

Agents of Socialization:
  1. Family. Early childhood socialization from before we are born (pink or blue wallpaper, followed by gendered toys).
Values - Parents act in ways that encourage their children to follow in their footsteps.
Wealthy encourage creativity/independence, poor tend to encourage conformity/discipline.
( a new study uncovers a similar phenomenon - self-advocacy and questioning vs. avoidance and deference ) 
Identity – race, class, religion. Religion is the odd one – what is a little Jewish boy, or a little Catholic girl? They don't know what that means, yet we call them that because we presume kids share their parents' religion.
Capital – economic capital (money), social capital (networks), cultural capital (knowledge).
"Capital" is just a resource – something you use to do something else.
Family and class also determine when you become an "adult," as do cultural factors. What does a year off after school mean if you are poor vs. rich?
Is adulthood when you can drink? When you can go off to war? When you can vote? When you become a parent? When you get a full time job and your own place?
  1. School.
    People with different backgrounds.
    More structured, bureaucratic authority.
    Gender socialization continues, boys aggressive, girls passive.
    Money can determine the value of education, as can cycles of poverty and Blocked Opportunity Structures.
    Schools have a "hidden curriculum" of values in addition to the regular, planned lessons and classes. Sports, spelling bees, grading curves, etc... teach competition as a value. Team projects can teach cooperation. Even here at WCTC, we're supposed to teach implicit lessons like getting yourself up on someone else's schedule, being responsible, meeting deadlines, interacting with people from different backgrounds, etc...
  1. Peer groups. Democratic/anarchic authority.
    Children learn autonomy, can discuss taboo topics.
    Homophily.
    Anticipatory socialization – the influence of groups you would like to join.
  1. Mass media. Impersonal, one-way transmission of memes.
    vast audience, cultural homogenizer. Lowest common denominator.  Can introduce new and different ideas, can educate.  But can also be sculpted into propaganda (spin) and reinforce prejudice and fear.
    Can promote stereotypes – twice as many blonde women as there are in real life. Everybody's attractive on T.V. unless the point of the character is to be unattractive, therefore if you feel you are not attractive you may feel something is wrong with you.
    Can desensitize us to violence.
  1. Others. Religion. Workplaces. Social clubs. Total institutions like prisons, psych wards, certain aspects of the military (boot camp).
Total institutions (p.80) explicitly re-socialize people.  It is their manifest function - not a latent function like with many of the above agents.
See Zimbardo on page 22. 
Cut off from outside, constant surveillance, professional authorities, minimization of self (standardization of hair, clothes, etc.)

4:00 - Life course stages.
Childhood – culturally defined, sometimes regardless of biological maturity.
Kids work in other countries. Middle ages depict kids as small adults. We are in a rich country so kids don't HAVE to work so our culture has shifted to define childhood as carefree and playful, and formal education has become important with industrialization.  But it wasn't always this way.
Are Piaget's stages (last time) moving up earlier and earlier?  When are kids "adults?"  In America we are rich and so have an extended childhood relative to the rest of the world, so we are concerned when kids grow up faster, or when there is pressure to grow up faster.
What about imposing adulthood and sexuality on children (Toddlers & Tiaras, etc...)?
DISCUSS: Where does this pressure come from?
kids' natural emulation of adults + cultural impetus from media + increasingly indulgent parents (perhaps trying to live vicariously through their children, like in Toddlers & Tiaras - but in doing so are imposing an adult frame of understanding childhood on their kids)
Adolescence – confusion and emotion come not just from biological puberty, but from social confusion over norms and status (anomia). Contradictions of being no longer children but not yet adults: can go to war but not drink, be sexy but don't have sex, be your own person but obey your parents...
Socially constructed since 1800's...
Working class = adults shortly after high school, start work and parenting.
Wealthy = adults around 30, after college, maybe grad school or traveling
Adulthood – support yourself, career goals, parenting, different for men and women, have to face aging which our culture doesn't like. (youth-worship, Ageism)
Old Age – retirement, growing elderly population (p.79 chart), health problems, social security?
Culture shapes our understanding of Age.  How do other cultures deal with age?  Respect for elders, power (gerontocracy), families take care of elders... 
Poverty, especially for elderly widows now who didn't work but were supported by husbands.
Although now we're seeing that more older women have worked and so have social security and/or pensions... also people are healthier now, less smokers, better medicine & nutrition, so can stay working longer.
Last article at the end (p.81): are we puppets responding to offstage direction?